How Loud is “Loud”?

Jim Edgar is one of our amazing and generous instructors. If you find this information helpful, consider joining us for Jim's Post-Production Polishing class starting November 2nd for more in-depth study of sound file processing.


The following was originally posted to Tuesday Tech Tips on justaskjimvo.studio

Following the discussion of Limiters a few weeks ago, I received a few questions about Loudness versus Peak.

When working in our home studios, it’s easy to get thrown off by the idea of “Loudness.” Part of the problem comes from the casual use of the word “loud” – I know there were times in my younger days when it was pointed out that my music was, in fact, “too loud” for other members of the household.

Before we began recording our own voices, we dealt only with playback volume. When we play audio back (or “monitor” it), we are controlling how comfortably the sound hits our hearing. If it’s too loud, we turn it down. If we need more detail, we turn it up.

However, when we are doing the recording, the key variable is the level of the input signal.

The level is controlled by an INPUT volume setting. Depending upon your recording chain, that might be a slider in software, a hardware dial on your USB-direct-connected microphone, or the control on your interface. It is independent from the idea of how loud it “sounds”.

I’ll typically recommend a value between -6 and -12 dB as a good target on the input. However, that’s actually a bit of a shorthand. The value I’m talking about is the Peak measurement of the recording, a momentary value for the loudest single cycle of the audio wave form.

Our hearing, however, is not that reactive to “Peak” values of single waves. It tends to be comparatively slow to react (remember there are hundreds of those single wave cycles going into our ears every second for sound in the speech range, and thousands per second for higher frequencies). We use Peak values for controlling our input, but those numbers aren’t addressing the overall acoustic energy – the true “Loudness”. I’ll come back to that in a second.

Why “Peak” values work for input

There are three reasons we typically focus on the Peak value when recording VO tracks:

Loudness differs from Peak

When we measure Loudness, we are describing the overall energy of the audio over a specific period of time. For much of what we deliver – particularly audiobook recordings, for example – we are concerned with the overall loudness of the entire file. The most common measurement scale here is either RMS (Root Mean Squared) or LUFS/LKFS (Loudness Units Full Scale / Loudness K-weighted Full Scale). The important distinction is that those values measure the energy of audio over time, as opposed to a single waveform Peak.

For example, in the audio below, there’s a single Peak that hits -0 dB, but the overall Loudness is relatively low –

Twisted Wave screen capture with Analyze function showing Peak Amplitude of the file at 0.00 dB and the Average RMS power at -36.75 dB RMS. The peak wave is highlighted to contrast the idea of a single cycle value versus the overall average of the RMS value.

If we simply highlight and attenuate the Peak (using Amplify and giving a negative value) that fixes the single wave. We could then amplify to make everything a little louder as we see here. Even though the Peak is lower, the RMS has been increased.

Twisted Wave screen capture with the Analyze function showing a lower Peak Amplitude value of -4.58 dB but a higher Average RMS value of -33.10 dB RMS
Here, I’ve manually attenuated the tall Peak from the first image by selecting that region and then using Amplify with a negative value. Then, I increased the overall Loudness by using Amplify on the entire file. At that point both the Peak and RMS increased in tandem.
Further resource: Tuesday Tech Tip – Why be Normal?

Using a dynamic control like a Limiter, we can force the RMS to be significantly higher, but control the maximum value for the Peaks. We’d end up with a “squashed” wave which is actually “louder” (the RMS is higher) even though the Peak height of the wave is lower.

Running the above audio through an aggressive Limiter creates a “squashed” wave with a low Peak but higher RMS Average. Further resource: Tuesday Tech Tip: Thinking About Limiters

If we were to listen to these three audio samples in the above order, each would sound a bit louder than the previous. That is what RMS and LUFS/LKFS scales describe by giving a numerical value to how we actually perceive sound. It’s why the “Normalize to -3 dB Peak” delivery approach listed on some online VO sites may not always be appropriate. A single waveform can throw that off measurement – it can sound “quieter” even though a single Peak is at a high value.

It would be really nice if there was an actual loudness delivery spec for auditions. Though there has been a bit of interest in that idea recently, it unfortunately has not yet gained momentum. So it falls to us, as voice actors, to understand how these values can work together. Understanding Loudness measurements can help you make corrections to deliver your audio at an appropriate and competitive level.

Read Next

Voice One Verve Articles

Event

Our Deepest Gratitude this Thanksgiving

Wishing you happiness and good company as we wind down the year

November 24, 2021
Read More
Article

Big Old Ugly Fear

Let’s tackle big, old, ugly fear. Here are five ways to conquer your fear of trying improv, or anything new.

November 17, 2021
Read More
Article

Tips for Toys, and Beyond!

We felt so inspired after our Professional Invitational with Rowen Wagner from Moose Toys, we just had to write about it!

November 10, 2021
Read More
Interview

Instructor Interview: Gavin Hammon and The Modern Announcer

Aaron asks Gavin a few questions about Commercial VO and his new class at Voice One.

November 3, 2021
Read More
Article

How Loud is “Loud”?

A Tech Tip clarification from our brilliant instructor Jim Edgar

October 20, 2021
Read More
Article

Take Off Your Mental Headphones

Three steps to stop listening to yourself while performing commercial VO

October 13, 2021
Read More
Classes

Halloween month means CHARACTER month!

Take a look at the awesome classes coming your way this month, and join us in-person in San Francisco or online via Zoom.

October 7, 2021
Read More
Article

October is Dyslexia Awareness Month

Many actors are affected by dyslexia, but it isn't talked about enough.

October 6, 2021
Read More
Classes

October 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you this month!

September 29, 2021
Read More
Article

"If it were easy, everyone would do it!"

Voice Acting is more than just reading, no matter the sales pitch.

September 15, 2021
Read More
Interview

VO On Air: A Conversation with Tom Celia

Interview and Q&A with Tom Celia - Recording Available!

September 3, 2021
Read More
Article

Dubs in the time of COVID

How the pandemic changed dubbing and what that means for the future

September 1, 2021
Read More
Classes

Announcing our next Professional Invitational guest

Join us on September 8 and meet Cliff!

September 1, 2021
Read More
Article

Troy Baker on Acting in Video Games

“I will quite often come out of the booth drenched in sweat, but those are the things that I live for.”

August 25, 2021
Read More
Promotion

End of Summer Special Offer

This weekend only! Save $50 on your class registration!

August 20, 2021
Read More
Article

The Unique Challenges of James McAvoy's First Video Game VO Gig

'Twelve Minutes' required much more time in the booth

August 18, 2021
Read More
Classes

This Week at Voice One (8/13/21-8/21/21)

A quick look at classes starting this weekend and next week!

August 13, 2021
Read More
Stories

Successes and Challenges for Trans and Non-Binary Voice Actors

Voice actor Kayleigh McKee discusses her experience in voiceover and progress in representation

August 11, 2021
Read More
Interview

Insights from Insiders: Andrea Toyias on Casting in Voice Over

Blizzard's Casting Director Wants You to Bring Truth to the Fantastic Worlds of Video Games

August 4, 2021
Read More
Interview

VO On Air: Cissy Jones, Melissa Hutchison, Gavin Hammon

Join us this Thursday (8/5) for a *FREE* Webinar!

August 3, 2021
Read More
Classes

August 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you this month!

August 1, 2021
Read More
Interview

Insights from Insiders: Brandon O'Neill

A Discussion of VO and Mocap in Video Games

July 28, 2021
Read More
Classes

Check out our "Pro Meet & Read" lineup for Fall 2021!

Meet and perform for some of the best in the industry!

July 28, 2021
Read More
Article

Auditioning for Apps and Podcasts

Making your audition stand out and connect to the listener is the route to success. Here are some great suggestions how.

July 21, 2021
Read More
Classes

Strengthen Your VO Core

Everything you need to know about why, how, and when to take the Voice One Core Curriculum this semester!

July 16, 2021
Read More
Article

The Sound of Influencers and its Influence

Standing out in a crowd is difficult, especially if you are consciously or unconsciously emulating what you've heard before.

July 14, 2021
Read More
Article

"The Audacity of Change" by Jim Edgar

What's up with the recent changes to Audacity?

July 7, 2021
Read More
Classes

In-Person Core Classes are Just a Few Weeks Away!

Entire Core Curriculum is available from July 19th to August 8th in our Summer Fast Track!

July 7, 2021
Read More
Interview

VO On Air: A Conversation with Tyler Rhoads

Interview and Q&A with Tyler Rhoads on July 9

July 5, 2021
Read More
Classes

Friday Nights at Voice One

We now have fun and affordable offerings for you every Friday night!

July 2, 2021
Read More
Article

Insights from Insiders: Carl Bishop's Experience as an LGBTQ+ Actor in VO

Much has changed in Voice Over in the past few decades.

June 30, 2021
Read More
Article

Fulfilling the Demand for Authenticity in Audiobooks

Tackling the issue of representation in the audiobooks industry comes with a number of unique concerns

June 23, 2021
Read More
Article

Insights from Insiders: Linda Lamontagne

An interview with a voice casting director on the state of the industry

June 16, 2021
Read More
Interview

Kelly Tran on Breaking into Animation

Kelly Tran's seeming sudden prominence in the public eye is rooted in years of dedication to the craft.

June 9, 2021
Read More
Interview

Sally Clawson on The Lisa Wentz Show!

A candid conversation on voice over

June 2, 2021
Read More
Classes

June 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you this month!

May 28, 2021
Read More
Classes

Nailing the Audition Guest Announcement - June 2021

Come meet our next guest talent agent!

May 28, 2021
Read More
Article

Working with Directors

Solid advice on being the voice actor that directors want in their projects.

May 26, 2021
Read More
Event

Our Next Professional Invitational Guest is...

Steve Pogatch – Lead Audio Producer – Pandora/Sirius XM/Stitcher (Studio Resonate)

May 20, 2021
Read More
Interview

Interview: Asian-American Representation In Anime

Emi Lo, Apphiya Yu, and Shawn Gann discuss their perspectives on Asian-American representation in Anime and more

May 19, 2021
Read More
Article

4 Potential Pitfalls That Bear Repeating

Knowing what works is great, but knowing what doesn't work can save you a lot of anguish.

May 12, 2021
Read More
Interview

Insights from Insiders: Sarah Natochenny of Pokémon on Acting

What makes acting in animation believable and bookable?

May 5, 2021
Read More
Classes

May 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you for May!

April 30, 2021
Read More
Article

Insights from Insiders: Anjali Bhimani's Advice for Actors

Anjali shares realistic advice from what she has learned over the course of her amazing career.

April 28, 2021
Read More
Article

Will there ever be an Oscar for Voice Performance?

Award season always brings up the question about recognition of voice acting by the Academy

April 21, 2021
Read More
Classes

Dive into the Deep-end of Dialects

Doug Honorof returns to Voice One this June

April 14, 2021
Read More
Interview

Interview with Doug Honorof

We spoke with the legendary dialect coach on learning accents

April 14, 2021
Read More
Article

Vocal Coaches on (Bad) Accents

It's a considerable feat to fool human ears!

April 14, 2021
Read More
Article

Cathy Ang on Imposter Syndrome

Embracing your "imperfections" can make you a better creative collaborator.

April 7, 2021
Read More
Event

A Conversation with Zehra Fazal

Interview and Q&A with Zehra Fazal on 2/8

April 1, 2021
Read More
Article

Animation and Video Games: Different Voices and Different Choices

It's not "one style fits all" in Character work.

March 31, 2021
Read More
Classes

April 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you this month!

March 31, 2021
Read More
Event

Announcing Our Next Professional Invitational Guest...

Mary Lynn Wissner, Award Winning Casting Director

March 18, 2021
Read More
Interview

Interview and Q&A with Ryan Colt Levy

Join us for a free webinar! March 17, 10am PST

March 17, 2021
Read More
Interview

VO Ace Spotlight: Cissy Jones

Two Interviews with this Phenomenal Voice Actor

March 17, 2021
Read More
Interview

Celebrating June Foray

One of the most highly influential players in voice acting history

March 10, 2021
Read More
Fun

Auditioning Advice from Bryan Cranston

A change in perspective can really change what you bring to the table!

March 3, 2021
Read More
Classes

March 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you this month!

March 1, 2021
Read More
Interview

Interview with Dani Chambers and Lee George

Dani and Lee speak about their histories with Anime, representation in voice acting, and inspiring fans to follow their dreams.

February 24, 2021
Read More
Event

Our guest for the February Professional Invitational is...

Cheryl Rosenthal, Video Producer and Director!

February 10, 2021
Read More
Classes

February 2021 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you in February!

January 29, 2021
Read More
Interview

Interview and Q&A with Julie Nathanson

Join us for a free webinar! February 4, 10am PST

January 28, 2021
Read More
Article

Insights for Insiders: Anne Ganguzza Breaks Down Brilliant Corporate Narration

We get to see how the VO Boss assesses a high quality corporate narration spot.

January 27, 2021
Read More
Article

Tech & Technique: Position, Position, Position

Jim Edgar shares some perspective on resolving changes in your space's sound over time.

January 20, 2021
Read More
Article

Insights for Insiders: Prepping for Audiobooks

Ann Richardson shares suggestions on audiobook narration that can help you and others in the process.

January 13, 2021
Read More
Article

The One New Year's Resolution Every Voice Actor Should Make

Sally suggests letting these four words become your mantra for 2021.

January 6, 2021
Read More
Article

ARTICLE: Goal Setting for Actors

Practical Advice for Achieving your Goals in Acting

December 30, 2020
Read More
Classes

January 2021 Classes Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you in January!

December 29, 2020
Read More
Interview

Interview with Cora Champommier

Tiburon Actress Discusses her Role in Pixar's Soul.

December 23, 2020
Read More
Article

Julianne Grossman: From Voicemail to Star Trek!

An intriguing evolution of a Voice Over career

December 16, 2020
Read More
Interview

Interview with Jess Harnell

Voice acting, Animaniacs, and more!

December 9, 2020
Read More
Promotion

Ho-Ho-Holiday Gift Guide

This holiday season put a little voice over in your gift basket!

December 7, 2020
Read More
News

Demo Recording at Voice One!

Listen to two wonderful demos fresh out of the studio! (plus learn more about our Demo Production process)

December 2, 2020
Read More
Article

Giving Thanks

Reflecting On A Transformative Year

November 25, 2020
Read More
Interview

Interview with Lake Bell

Lake Bell talks about getting into the VO business and what it means for her.

November 18, 2020
Read More
Classes

Year End Classes 2020

We're buttoning up 2020 with some exciting classes!

November 12, 2020
Read More
Event

Our next Professional Invitational guest is...

Announcing December's Professional Invitational guest!

November 11, 2020
Read More
Article

Saturday Morning TV is Bringing in More International Cartoons to the US Market

Texas-based company is making more opportunity for English dubbing beyond Anime

November 4, 2020
Read More
Classes

November 2020 Class Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you you this coming month!

November 1, 2020
Read More
Article

You'd Know Them If You Heard Them

Prolific voice actors of animation talk about their careers

October 28, 2020
Read More
Interview

Shakespeare and the Voice

An interview with Linda Gates

October 21, 2020
Read More
Interview

Interview with Darin De Paul

How he got into voice acting in video games.

October 14, 2020
Read More
Article

Strike a Pose: Creating (and Maintaining) Characters

by Clay Robeson October 1, 2020

October 1, 2020
Read More
Event

Our next Professional Invitational guest is...

Announcing October's Professional Invitational guest!

October 1, 2020
Read More
Article

Brand Voice

As a voice actor, you are your brand, but you can also become part of a company's "brand voice"

September 30, 2020
Read More
Classes

October 2020 Classes Calendar

Check out what we have in store for you you this coming month!

September 25, 2020
Read More
Classes

This Week at Voice One (9/21-9/27)

A quick look at classes starting this week and next week!

September 21, 2020
Read More
Classes

Voice One Welcomes Kay Bess!

Voice Actor phenom here to teach our VO Master Class

September 17, 2020
Read More