Jim Edgar is one of our amazing and generous instructors. If you find this information helpful, consider joining us for Jim's Post-Production Polishing class starting November 2nd for more in-depth study of sound file processing.
The following was originally posted to Tuesday Tech Tips on justaskjimvo.studio
Following the discussion of Limiters a few weeks ago, I received a few questions about Loudness versus Peak.
When working in our home studios, it’s easy to get thrown off by the idea of “Loudness.” Part of the problem comes from the casual use of the word “loud” – I know there were times in my younger days when it was pointed out that my music was, in fact, “too loud” for other members of the household.
Before we began recording our own voices, we dealt only with playback volume. When we play audio back (or “monitor” it), we are controlling how comfortably the sound hits our hearing. If it’s too loud, we turn it down. If we need more detail, we turn it up.
However, when we are doing the recording, the key variable is the level of the input signal.
The level is controlled by an INPUT volume setting. Depending upon your recording chain, that might be a slider in software, a hardware dial on your USB-direct-connected microphone, or the control on your interface. It is independent from the idea of how loud it “sounds”.
I’ll typically recommend a value between -6 and -12 dB as a good target on the input. However, that’s actually a bit of a shorthand. The value I’m talking about is the Peak measurement of the recording, a momentary value for the loudest single cycle of the audio wave form.
Our hearing, however, is not that reactive to “Peak” values of single waves. It tends to be comparatively slow to react (remember there are hundreds of those single wave cycles going into our ears every second for sound in the speech range, and thousands per second for higher frequencies). We use Peak values for controlling our input, but those numbers aren’t addressing the overall acoustic energy – the true “Loudness”. I’ll come back to that in a second.
There are three reasons we typically focus on the Peak value when recording VO tracks:
When we measure Loudness, we are describing the overall energy of the audio over a specific period of time. For much of what we deliver – particularly audiobook recordings, for example – we are concerned with the overall loudness of the entire file. The most common measurement scale here is either RMS (Root Mean Squared) or LUFS/LKFS (Loudness Units Full Scale / Loudness K-weighted Full Scale). The important distinction is that those values measure the energy of audio over time, as opposed to a single waveform Peak.
For example, in the audio below, there’s a single Peak that hits -0 dB, but the overall Loudness is relatively low –
If we simply highlight and attenuate the Peak (using Amplify and giving a negative value) that fixes the single wave. We could then amplify to make everything a little louder as we see here. Even though the Peak is lower, the RMS has been increased.
Using a dynamic control like a Limiter, we can force the RMS to be significantly higher, but control the maximum value for the Peaks. We’d end up with a “squashed” wave which is actually “louder” (the RMS is higher) even though the Peak height of the wave is lower.
If we were to listen to these three audio samples in the above order, each would sound a bit louder than the previous. That is what RMS and LUFS/LKFS scales describe by giving a numerical value to how we actually perceive sound. It’s why the “Normalize to -3 dB Peak” delivery approach listed on some online VO sites may not always be appropriate. A single waveform can throw that off measurement – it can sound “quieter” even though a single Peak is at a high value.
It would be really nice if there was an actual loudness delivery spec for auditions. Though there has been a bit of interest in that idea recently, it unfortunately has not yet gained momentum. So it falls to us, as voice actors, to understand how these values can work together. Understanding Loudness measurements can help you make corrections to deliver your audio at an appropriate and competitive level.
Pedro Pascal, The Mandalorian, and Voiceover
With 148 Character VO Emmy Award nominees, who stands out and why?
A hilarious social media handle has dedicated itself to narrating animals' inner monologues.
Pros and cons of celebrity voice acting
Sarah Natochenny voiced Pokémon’s Ash Ketchum for 17 years. Q&A.
Warning -- spoilers ahead! Click to read about voice actor cameos in The Last of Us.
Erika sits down with Marvin Greene to discuss the importance of studying the craft, his favorite breakthroughs, and more!
Get out of your own way and own your year in VO by applying this advice. Here are four simple steps to help you reach your goals!
Cissy Jones, Melissa Hutchison, and Gavin Hammon share advice, discuss their careers, experience, and day to day life as working voice actors.